- Release year: 2026
- Director: James Gray.
- Producers: Andrea Bucko, Leonardo Maria Del Vecchio, Gary Farkas, James Gray, Anthony Katagas, Andrea Leone, Raffaella Leone, Marco Perego, Carlo Salem, and Rodrigo Teixeira.
- Screenplay by: James Gray.
- Cinematography by: Joaquín Baca-Asay.
- Music by: Christopher Spelman.
Synopsis: In an attempt to launch a business, two brothers get tangled with the wrong crowd, leading to catastrophic consequences.
Shotgun Commentary: It is a crime that a movie with a cast this good is so horribly bad.

Review
Paper Tiger is an interesting exploration of the fragility of one’s life and how it can be completely destroyed by the smallest of things. The title references the expression of Chinese origin used to refer to a person or a system that appears to be strong and powerful on the outside but is actually weak and harmless. Now, anyone knowing this would know they are probably about to watch a big drama with lots of suffering. Yours truly, was not among those people when watching the film at the Leiden International Film Festival.
What a time to be alive
The story is quite simple. Retired cop-turned-businessman Gary Pearl (Adam Driver) convinces his engineer brother Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller) to go into business with him. The plan is to assess the operation that some Russian immigrants are doing along a canal to help them develop their business legally. Iwin gets way too excited about the prospect of making money and goes into the Russian site one night to show his sons around. The Russians do not like that and go into attack mode. After scaring Irwin and his kids half to death, they ask for retribution from Gary, but he has no intention of working for the Russians anymore. This leads to a whole predicament.
There is definitely a strong influence from 1973’s Serpico in Gary’s subplot. After all, the tale takes place in the late 60s or 70s, going by the comments made in the film, so both stories are not too far apart in time either. Gary “manages to get out clean”, an interesting phrase used by one of his ex-partners that tells you just how common and spread corruption is within the NYPD. This cleanliness gives Gary a lot of fame but also raises a lot of envy, a complex double-edged sword that makes the character the most compelling of the production by far.
Saving a house on fire
As for the other characters, not even stars of the size of Miles Teller and Scarlett Johansson can make Irwin and his wife, Hester, memorable. As expected, they play their roles perfectly, but the story is just not there. Every single dialogue makes you wish it was over before it begins. No amount of charm and great acting manages to save a single conversation. Not to mention Hester’s subplot, while compelling, is annoyingly predictable and has the cheesiest ending possible.

Plus, there is one small issue with her character. An issue that, while superficial and not relevant to the plot, does influence the viewing quite a lot. What the hell is that hair?! It must have been hard to find a wig as ugly as that one, but hell if it doesn’t completely take you out of the scene with every single appearance. That monstrosity is so hideous it actually manages to capture your attention no matter how dramatic the moment is.
All in all, Paper Tiger is a nice period drama for those of you who like to suffer for the sake of suffering. If you are not a big, BIG fan of dramas, maybe give this one a skip. The star-studded cast is definitely not worth its glacial pace. And if anyone happens to introduce it to you as a Western, like it happened during my screening, DO NOT BELIEVE THEM.
Paper Tiger is still running at LIFF, get your tickets here!
Advice to take from this movie:
- If a deal sounds too good to be true. It probably is.
- Bit of an obvious one, but do not mess with shady people.
- Sometimes you need to prioritise yourself.
What’s your take? Have you watched Paper Tiger? Don’t hesitate to let me know your thoughts in the comments section below, or leave a message on my contact page! For more reviews and cinema-related articles, check out the rest of my blog! 😀
